The New Standard: Analyzing the 2024 NFL Rookie of the Year Finalists
NEW YORK, NY — The NFL officially narrowed the 2024 rookie class to ten finalists for the Offensive and Defensive Rookie of the Year awards. While draft pedigree often dictates early expectations, these ten players secured their spots by becoming high-leverage assets for their respective coordinators. This year’s finalists represent a shift toward specialized, “pro-ready” skill sets that allowed them to bypass the typical rookie learning curve.
New England’s TreVeyon Henderson is looking to win a CFP National Championship and Super Bowl in back-to-back years 🔥
CFP National Title 🏆
Super Bowl LX ⏳ pic.twitter.com/QDFN0fEs8g— NFL on ESPN (@ESPNNFL) January 26, 2026
Offense: Quarterback Gravity and Historical Usage
The Offensive Rookie of the Year (OROY) list is headlined by five players who occupied a massive share of their team’s offensive identity. **Jayden Daniels** remains the frontrunner from a purely analytical standpoint; he finished the regular season ranking in the **top 10 among all quarterbacks in EPA (Expected Points Added) per play**. His ability to force defenses into a “plus-one” box to account for his rushing threat opened up the intermediate passing game for Washington in a way they haven’t seen in decades.
However, the most statistically anomalous season belongs to **Brock Bowers**. The Raiders tight end didn’t just have a good rookie year; he had one of the most productive seasons for a tight end in NFL history, rookie or veteran. Bowers finished with **94 receptions**, becoming the first rookie at his position to lead his team in target share since the merger. His tactical value comes from “positionless” alignment—the Raiders used him as an in-line blocker, a slot receiver, and even a backfield lead-blocker, making him a schematic headache for defensive coordinators who rely on personnel-based play calls.
- Jayden Daniels (QB, Commanders): 3,500+ pass yards / 700+ rush yards.
- Caleb Williams (QB, Bears): Recovered from a slow start to rank 5th in “Big Time Throws” over the final six weeks.
- Brock Bowers (TE, Raiders): Broke the all-time rookie reception record for tight ends.
- Malik Nabers (WR, Giants) & Marvin Harrison Jr. (WR, Cardinals): Both surpassed 1,000 yards despite playing in offenses with bottom-tier pass protection.
Defense: The Pressure Principle and Lockdown Length
The Defensive Rookie of the Year (DROY) race highlights the value of immediate impact in the pass-rush and secondary. **Jared Verse** (Rams) stands out as a tactical outlier. Verse led all rookies with **62 total pressures**, proving that his bull-rush translates instantly to the pro level. He filled the gap left by Aaron Donald by forcing double-teams at a rate usually reserved for five-year veterans.
In the secondary, **Quinyon Mitchell** (Eagles) and **Terrion Arnold** (Lions) validated the trend of targeting long, physical corners in the first round. Mitchell, specifically, allowed a **passer rating of just 78.4** when targeted in man-coverage. His ability to “gate” receivers at the line of scrimmage allowed the Eagles to stay in their preferred five-man pressure looks without worrying about getting beat over the top.
Inside the Huddle
“You aren’t just looking at young guys with upside anymore. You’re looking at the primary reasons why these teams are in the playoff hunt. If you don’t account for Jared Verse on the edge or Jayden Daniels in the read-option, you’re going to lose the game. Plain and simple.” — Current NFL Director of Player Personnel
The Bottom Line & What’s Next
The financial implications for these ten players are massive. Under the current rookie wage scale, these franchises are getting Pro Bowl-level production for a fraction of the market rate. The Commanders and Bears, specifically, are now in a “Super Bowl Window” where they can aggressively spend on free agents while their elite quarterbacks are on fixed, low-cost contracts.
Expect the final voting to be revealed during Super Bowl week. While Daniels and Verse are the betting favorites, the historical volume of Brock Bowers could make the OROY race much tighter than people expect. Watch for these players to be the centerpieces of the 2025 offseason marketing—they aren’t just rookies anymore; they are the new faces of their franchises. The shift from “prospect” to “star” happened in record time this season.
